Saves vs Fresh Pins on Pinterest

Understanding the ideal blend of Pin content for effective Pinterest marketing

In this lesson you'll learn:

  • The difference between Saves and Fresh Pins (and why you should optimize for both)
  • Why Fresh Pins are the key to successful Pinterest marketing
  • How to quickly create the Fresh content Pinterest craves (and rewards)

It's not uncommon to hear from a small business owner who is frustrated by their Pinterest marketing. They're active and engaged on Pinterest — pinning, re-pinning, saving everyday — and yet their traffic has plateaued and remains stagnant in spite of their best effort.

The problem and solution lies in understanding the powerful duo of Saves and Fresh Pins on Pinterest. These two elements are the cornerstones of Pinterest success, yet many marketers overlook their distinct roles and combined potential. By starting your Pinterest marketing with a thorough understanding of their roles, you can gain momentum and grow your organic traffic faster.  

Decoding the Pinterest lingo: Saves vs. Fresh Pins

What are saves?

Saves are when a Pinterest user adds someone else's pin to one of their own boards. It's akin to bookmarking content for future reference or sharing it with their followers.

  • Social Proof: Saves signal to Pinterest that your content is valuable and engaging.
  • Extended Reach: Each save exposes your pin to a new audience—the followers of the person who saved it.
  • Longevity: Saved pins can resurface and gain traction long after the original post date.

Think of Saves like word-of-mouth referrals. When someone saves your pin, they're endorsing your content to their network.

A pyramid-shaped diagram shows how Pinterest saves contribute to three areas: Social Proof, Extended Reach, and Longevity. An arrow pointing from a "Save" button to the pyramid illustrates the impact flow.

What are "Fresh Pins"?

Fresh Pins are entirely new content that haven't been shared on Pinterest before. To the Pinterest algorithm, it's original content that adds something new to the platform.

  • Algorithm Favoritism: Pinterest's algorithm favors Fresh Pins, giving them a priority in user feeds.
  • Enhanced Visibility: Fresh content keeps your profile active and engaging.
  • Opportunities for Engagement: Each Fresh Pin is a new chance to attract saves, clicks, and follows.

Consider Fresh Pins as eye-catching window displays that draw customers into your store.

A pyramid-shaped diagram illustrates the benefits of fresh pins on Pinterest. Arrows highlight areas: Algorithm Favoritism, Enhanced Visibility, and Opportunities for Engagement, with a Pinterest logo nearby.

Fresh Pins in depth: What, exactly, makes a "Fresh Pin," fresh?

So Pinterest wants, and rewards, Fresh Pins, but what does it interpret as "fresh?" If you change the Pin title, does that count? Do you need to change the title and image?

This is what you need to remember:

A Fresh Pin is content that has a unique: URL, unique image, and/or unique title and description.

And, Pinterest prioritizes them in that order. Pinterest's algorithm will view unique URLs as "more fresh" than Pins with the same URL but with only a unique image or unique title and description. If two Pins share the same URL, but one has a unique image and the other has a unique title and description, Pinterest will prioritize the one with the unique image (Remember, Pinterest is a visual first platform!)

Pinterest content creation: What this means for your Pinterest marketing strategy

You're probably realizing that to create Fresh Pins with unique URLs you're going to need a lot of content! Tools like Tailwind's Ghostwriter are a huge help by generating high-quality blog content quickly, but it's still challenging to produce enough content to meet the recommended Pinning frequency of 5-25 times per day.

In an ideal world, you'd be linking to unique content every time you Pin, but that isn't necessary (or recommended) to get great results from your Pinterest marketing. Pinterest still views unique images and titles and descriptions as fresh so the key to get your Pin volume up is to create multiple Pins from each piece of content.

With tools like Tailwind Create, which helps you quickly create professional looking Pin images, Ghostwriter, which helps you write compelling keyword-focused titles and descriptions, and a Pinterest scheduler built for bulk Pin creation and scheduling, like Tailwind's, you'll be able to quickly create and schedule 5, 10, or even 15 unique Pins from a single piece of content.

So don't feel overwhelmed! It is a lot of work if you were doing it all manually but that's why time-saving tools like Tailwind are essential for successful Pinterest marketing.

The power duo: Why both saves and fresh Pins matter

Understanding the distinct advantages of Saves and Fresh Pins—and how they complement each other—is crucial for a winning Pinterest strategy.

The impact of saves

1. Amplified reach through social proof

When users save your pins, it signals to Pinterest that your content resonates with the audience. This social proof can boost your content's distribution.

Expert Insight:

Saves are a strong indicator of quality. They tell the algorithm that your content is worth sharing, which can exponentially increase its reach." — Kevin Lorenz, Pinterest Marketing Expert

2. Long-term visibility

Saved pins have a longer lifespan. They can resurface weeks or even months later, continuing to drive traffic to your site.

3. Enhanced audience targeting

As more users save your content, Pinterest gains insights into who engages with your pins, refining how and where your content appears.

A circular diagram breaks down the effects of Pinterest saves into three segments: Amplified Reach, Long-Term Visibility, and Enhanced Targeting. Each segment includes a brief description of its benefit, with a central "Save" button icon.

The advantages of Fresh Pins

1. Algorithmic preference

Pinterest prioritizes Fresh Pins in user feeds, offering greater initial exposure compared to repins or reshared content.

2. Relevance to trends

Creating Fresh Pins around trending topics or seasonal events increases the chances of your content being discovered.

3. Content diversification

Fresh Pins allow you to showcase different aspects of your brand through various formats:

  • Standard Pins: Classic images or graphics.
  • Video Pins: Engaging motion content.
  • Idea Pins: Multi-page content perfect for tutorials or storytelling.
  • Product Pins: Directly link users to purchase pages.

Strategies for optimizing Saves and Fresh Pins

Leveraging both Saves and Fresh Pins requires a balanced and strategic approach.

1. Create a balanced content calendar

Plan your content to include a mix of Fresh Pins and content designed to encourage Saves.

  • Consistency is key: Regularly posting Fresh Pins keeps your profile active.
  • Quality over quantity: Focus on creating high-quality pins that users want to save.
Pro tip: Use tools like Tailwind's SmartSchedule to optimize your pinning schedule for when your audience is most active.

2. Optimize with keywords

Incorporate relevant keywords in your pin titles and descriptions to improve discoverability.

  • Research trends: Use Pinterest Trends to find popular keywords.
  • Natural integration: Write descriptions that flow naturally and avoid keyword stuffing.

3. Craft high-quality visuals

Visual appeal is critical on Pinterest.

  • Use high-resolution images: Clear, eye-catching images stand out.
  • Brand consistency: Maintain a consistent color scheme and style.
  • Text overlays: Add concise and compelling text to convey your message quickly.

4. Encourage engagement

  • Calls to Action (CTA): Include prompts like "Save this for later" or "Click to learn more."
  • Engage with your audience: Respond to comments and engage with users who interact with your pins.

5. Analyze and adapt

  • Monitor performance: Use Pinterest Analytics to track which pins generate the most saves and engagement.
  • Adjust your strategy: Focus on creating more content similar to your top-performing pins.
A list of strategies in colorful arrow-shaped blocks includes: Stay Informed About Trends, Diversify Pin Types, Utilize Hashtags, Optimize for Mobile, and Leverage Tailwind Communities. Each strategy is paired with a brief explanatory note.

Saves and Fresh Pins, when used strategically, are the key to growing your reach and influence on Pinterest. Now that you understand their unique roles and how they complement each other, you can craft a robust Pinterest strategy that drives traffic, engagement, and ultimately, growth for your business.

Key takeaways:

  • Balance is key — regularly post Fresh Pins while encouraging Saves.
  • Quality over Quantity — focus on creating valuable, high-quality content.
  • Engage and Analyze — interact with your audience and continuously adapt based on performance insights.